Speaker’s election: Two left in competition to reinstate John Bercow

6 min read

Media captionJohn Bercow’s many noted moments as Speaker of a House

MPs are voting between a final dual possibilities to attain John Bercow as Speaker, in what is a initial selecting for a post in some-more than a decade.

In a third turn of voting Sir Lindsay Hoyle perceived a many votes during 267, followed by Chris Bryant with 169 and Dame Eleanor Laing was separated with 127.

The Speaker keeps sequence in Commons debates and calls MPs to speak.

The outcome of a final list is approaching about 20:00 GMT.

Seven possibilities were creatively in a running.

Having perceived a slightest series of votes, Dame Rosie Winterton had to leave a competition in a second turn of voting and Harriet Harman willingly withdrew her candidacy.

Labour MP Meg Hillier and Conservative Sir Edward Leigh were knocked out in a initial turn of a competition after receiving 10 and 11 votes respectively.

Mr Bercow stood down final week after an eventful and frequently argumentative decade in a Speaker’s chair. His abdication as MP for Buckingham was strictly reliable on Monday.

What were a candidates’ pitches?

Ken Clarke

Image copyright
UK Parliament/ Jessica Taylor

Image caption

Ken Clarke is heading a proceedings

The initial to pronounce was Labour’s Dame Rosie Winterton. She pronounced a Speaker’s pursuit was “not to browbeat record or pronounce for Parliament”, and betrothed to “douse a abandon not flow petrol on them”.

Another Labour MP Chris Bryant pronounced he believed in “a Speaker who will mount by a rules, who is totally just and who knows Erskine May [the parliamentary sequence book] behind to front”, adding: “I’ve got it fibbing by my bedside.”

He also affianced to finish clapping in a cover and “sort out a wi-fi” – pledges that were themselves met with clapping from those listening.

  • John Bercow bows out as Commons Speaker
  • How MPs will select a subsequent Speaker
  • What’s a purpose of a Speaker in Parliament?

Conservative Sir Edward Leigh pronounced a Speaker should “submerge their impression in a job” and be “a still voice”.

He also pronounced a refuge of parliamentary buildings should be finished “in a interests of a paymaster – a taxpayers”. “We can't rubbish billions of pounds,” he said.

Current emissary Speaker Eleanor Laing voiced unhappiness during a series of MPs determining not to run again during a Dec selecting and vowed to mount adult for all members if comparison for a job.

She pronounced Parliament indispensable to “escape from a hierarchical structures that concede bullying to take root”.

Also addressing a theme of bullying, Labour’s Meg Hillier pronounced MPs indispensable to strengthen staff in a House, warning bullying “will turn a subsequent losses scandal”.

Mr Bercow was criticised for not doing some-more to tackle allegations of bullying and nuisance in a Commons, and was himself indicted of mistreating several members of staff, that he denied.

Chris Bryant

Image copyright
UK Parliament/ Jessica Taylor

Image caption

Chris Bryant certified to gripping a book on parliamentary procession by his bedside

Another stream emissary Speaker, Sir Lindsay Hoyle, pronounced he had introduced confidence measures for MPs “so we can feel safe”.

“I will not let we down,” he betrothed MPs.

Former emissary personality of a Labour Party Harriet Harman was final to make her pitch, earnest to take on a fourth emissary drawn from one of a smaller parties.

She pronounced she had “an unparallel record of reform”, indicating to her debate to concede profound MPs and new relatives to opinion by proxy.

The possibilities done their pitches underneath a gawk of former Speaker Betty Boothroyd. Labour MP Stella Creasy got a design of a baroness sitting in a gallery

Skip Instagram post by stellacreasy

Instagram post by stellacreasy: There couldn’t be a some-more iconic parliamentarian examination over us currently ...#teambetty
Image Copyright stellacreasy

Presentational white space

How will a opinion unfold?

Candidates indispensable a support of during slightest 12 MPs, 3 of whom have to be from a opposite party, in sequence to be authorised to take part.

MPs have 20 mins to opinion in a tip ballot. It will take about 45 mins to count them.

If no claimant receives some-more half of a votes, a particular who receives a slightest votes will dump out, as will anyone who obtains reduction than 5% of a sum cast.

After any round, there will be a 10-minute duration for possibilities to withdraw.

MPs will afterwards continue to opinion until one claimant obtains some-more than half of a votes. The routine is being overseen by Ken Clarke, who as Father of a House is a long-serving MP in a Commons.

Who was in a running?

Sir Lindsay Hoyle

Image copyright
UK Parliament/ Jessica Taylor

Image caption

Labour MP Sir Lindsay Hoyle is regarded as a frontrunner for a role

Harriet Harman

Image copyright
UK Parliament/ Jessica Taylor

Image caption

Labour’s Harriet Harman has pronounced she wants to put an finish to “the Old Boys’ Club” in Parliament

Dame Eleanor Laing

Image copyright
UK Parliament/ Jessica Taylor

Image caption

Dame Eleanor Laing has pronounced she would “do things differently” from Mr Bercow

The 7 contenders during a start of a competition were:

  • Chris Bryant – former apportion and shade Commons leader; Labour MP for Rhondda given 2001
  • Harriet Harman – former apportion and emissary Labour leader; Labour MP given 1982, for Peckham and a inheritor subdivision Camberwell
  • Meg Hillier – president of a Public Accounts Committee and former minister; Labour MP for Hackney South and Shoreditch given 2005
  • Sir Lindsay Hoyle – inaugurated Labour MP for Chorley in 1997; inaugurated emissary Speaker in 2010
  • Dame Eleanor Laing – inaugurated Conservative MP for Epping Forest in 1997; inaugurated emissary Speaker in 2013
  • Sir Edward Leigh – Conservative MP for Gainsborough given 1983; former authority of a Public Accounts Committee
  • Dame Rosie Winterton – inaugurated Labour MP for Doncaster Central in 1997; former Labour arch whip; inaugurated emissary Speaker in 2017

BBC parliamentary match Mark D’Arcy pronounced many observers believed Sir Lindsay – who has been Mr Bercow’s comparison emissary for years – was a frontrunner.

“As Chairman of Ways and Means, he chairs Budget debates and selects amendments for cabinet theatre record on bills, and has had copiousness of event to denote his credentials,” a match says.

Sir Lindsay pronounced MPs subsidy him enclosed Conservative Charles Walker, who was one of Mr Bercow’s pivotal allies during his tenure, former sports apportion Tracey Crouch and Brexit-backing Labour MP Caroline Flint.

Image Copyright @LindsayHoyle_MP

Twitter post by @LindsayHoyle_MP: Thanks to all those who nominated me to be Speaker@CharlesWalkerGB @marionfellows @tracey_crouch @MarshadeCordova @DavidCrausby @joanryanEnfield @SeemaKennedy @Pauline_Latham @KevanJonesMP @SirRogerGale @William_Wragg @Chris_Matheson @khalid4PB @CarolineFlintMP @Jamie4North 👇
Image Copyright @LindsayHoyle_MP

Presentational white space

He perceived an early boost when former Conservative apportion Shailesh Vara, one of a outsiders in a contest, pronounced he was pulling out and would be voting for his Labour colleague.

Skip Twitter post by @ShaileshVara

End of Twitter post by @ShaileshVara

Presentational white space

What is a Speaker’s role?

The purpose of a Speaker has come underneath augmenting inspection over a past few years – and Mr Bercow has been both praised for boosting a change of backbench MPs and criticised for stretching parliamentary rules.

Some have also indicted him of not being just when it comes to Brexit.

The Speaker is obliged for selecting that amendments can be voted on – a energy that has valid quite poignant in a Brexit process.

He is also in assign of support parliamentary rules, and Mr Bercow twice hurt some MPs by refusing to concede a supervision to reason another opinion on an already deserted Brexit deal.

The Speaker can also assent MPs to ask obligatory questions whereby supervision ministers are summoned to a House of Commons over a time-sensitive or critical matter.

During his years in a role, Mr Bercow dramatically increasing a series of obligatory questions asked.

Presentational grey line

Analysis: Easy win or tactical battle

By Mark D’Arcy, a BBC’s parliamentary correspondent

So what competence MPs wish in a new Speaker? First, there seems be an ardour for a opposite character – an finish to Bercow-esque verbosity and those five-minute appeals for brevity, as good as for an finish to a kind of clashes with MPs that a over Speaker was disposed to.

Remember his red-faced finger-jabbing strife with a afterwards Chief Whip Patrick McLoughlin, or this week’s squabble with long-time Bercow censor Andrew Bridgen?

Then there’s a many some-more critical regard about a Speaker’s unconditional powers to make a manners in a Commons, a energy that saw him needing amendments to Business of a House motions that were ostensible to be taken “forthwith” – that many MPs believed meant they could not be amended.

Given no one celebration has a infancy in a House, a winning claimant will be a one many able of reaching opposite celebration lines, and building a infancy out of factions of a categorical parties, a members of a smaller parties and their personal supporters.

Those seen as celebration gladiators initial and inaugural might find that tough to do.

Leave your vote

0 points
Upvote Downvote



Forgot password?

Enter your account data and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Your password reset link appears to be invalid or expired.

Log in

Privacy Policy

Add to Collection

No Collections

Here you'll find all collections you've created before.